## Code Review - PASS ### Implementation Verified **Changes Made (agents.rb):** **1. Planner Banner - "TICKET CREATION RULES" section added:** ``` ❌ DO NOT add "Files to Create" or "Files to Modify" sections ❌ DO NOT specify exact file paths in tickets ✅ DO describe the desired outcome and what needs to work ✅ DO provide context, constraints, and technical notes ✅ DO let workers discover which files need changes ``` - Includes clear examples of BAD ("Files to Modify") vs GOOD ("What You're Building") - Explains WHY: "File lists constrain thinking" - Shows pattern: Describe outcomes → Workers explore → Find all affected files **2. Orchestrator Banner - "TICKET CREATION/UPDATE RULES" section added:** - Same prohibitions for ticket creation and updates - Additional note: "focus on WHAT needs to happen, not WHICH files" - Ensures consistency across ticket creation paths **3. Acceptance Criteria Met:** - ✅ Planner banner updated with "no file lists" rule - ✅ Orchestrator banner updated with "no file lists" rule - ✅ Examples of bad vs good ticket descriptions - ✅ Clear explanation of why file lists are problematic **4. Quality Notes:** - Banner formatting matches existing style (boxed sections) - Examples are concrete and actionable - Reasoning (WHY) helps agents understand the purpose - Applies to both creation (Planner) and updates (Orchestrator) **PR Status:** OPEN - Awaiting merge by human/PO approval. Ticket can proceed to pending_approval after PR is merged.