## Code Review - FAIL ### Critical Regression: git-workflow Simplified The PR REPLACES the comprehensive `git-workflow` skill (from PR #45/ticket #97) with a simplified version that removes important features: **Removed Features:** 1. **Stacked PRs (Scenario 3)** - This is CRITICAL because: - Epic #79 requires phased development - Ticket #96 (auto-block dependencies) was specifically built to enable proper phased development - Removing stacked PR support undermines the ability to do Phase 1 → Phase 2 → Phase 3 workflows 2. **Conventional commit format** - Removes `type(scope): subject` standardization 3. **Quick Reference table** - Helpful lookup guide removed 4. **Detailed examples** - Reduces clarity for edge cases ### What Should Have Happened The ticket description says "Extract critical workflows to skills" - but the git-workflow skill was already extracted in PR #45. This PR should have: - Created the NEW skills (orchestrator-workflow, review-workflow, worker-boundaries) - LEFT git-workflow AS-IS (since it was already properly implemented) ### Acceptance Criteria Check The ticket states "Agents still follow correct workflows" - but removing stacked PR support means agents will NOT follow the correct phased development workflow. ### Required Fix 1. **Restore git-workflow SKILL.md to the PR #45 version** (keep comprehensive version) 2. Keep the new skills (orchestrator-workflow, review-workflow, worker-boundaries) as they look correct 3. Update PR to only ADD new skills without modifying existing git-workflow