# Reviewer Audit - PR #17 ## Overview Reviewing PR #17 which implements WebSocket-based agent coordination for autonomous agent workflow. ## Files Changed | File | Changes | |------|---------| | app/channels/agent_channel.rb | +14/-3 | | app/controllers/api/v1/mcp_controller.rb | +42 | | app/jobs/orchestrator_ping_job.rb | +35 (new) | | app/models/agent.rb | +14/-1 | | config/recurring.yml | +10 | | db/migrate/20251223130150_add_availability_status_to_agents.rb | +7 (new) | | db/schema.rb | +4/-1 | ## Subtask Review ### Subtask #63: Agent Status Tracking ✓ IMPLEMENTED - `availability_status` enum (idle: 0, busy: 1) ✓ - `availability_updated_at` timestamp ✓ - `available_for_work` scope ✓ - `idle_for?(duration)` instance method ✓ ### Subtask #64: MCP Tools for Status Management ✓ IMPLEMENTED - `mark_busy` tool ✓ - `mark_idle` tool ✓ ### Subtask #65: OrchestratorPingJob ⚠️ PARTIAL - Job runs every 30 seconds ✓ - Checks if Orchestrator idle for 2+ minutes ✓ - Broadcasts ping ✓ **ISSUE:** Only handles single orchestrator: `Agent.find_by(agent_type: "orchestrator")` finds first across ALL projects. ### Subtask #66: AgentChannel Logging Only ✓ IMPLEMENTED ## Critical Issues ### 1. MISSING: Orchestrator Work Assignment Logic ⛔ CRITICAL The PR implements the infrastructure (ping job, status tracking, MCP tools) but does NOT implement the actual Orchestrator logic to: - Query available agents - Check pending_audit tickets - Assign work to workers - Broadcast assignments via AgentChannel ### 2. Missing `availability_status` Filter on `list_members` ⚠️ MEDIUM The `list_members` tool supports `role` and `active` filters, but NOT `availability_status`. The ticket indicates: > "Check: `list_members(role: "worker", status: "idle")`" Currently `status` filters AASM status, NOT availability_status. ### 3. No Tests ⚠️ MEDIUM No test coverage for new functionality. ## Decision **RETURN TO WORKER** - Missing core Orchestrator assignment logic described in ticket.