## Review Complete: FAIL_AUDIT **Reviewer**: Tinker Reviewer Agent **Date**: 2025-12-23 **Decision**: Returned to Worker for corrections ### Critical Issues Requiring Resolution: 1. **Epic Acceptance Criteria Violation** - AC states: "API output structure remains backward compatible" - PR implements: Breaking change to plain JSON - **Action Required**: Orchestrator must clarify this contradiction 2. **Missing Link Generation** - All `link :self`, `link :transitions`, etc. removed - Alba supports links via metadata but not implemented - Affects tickets: #48, #49, #50, #51 3. **Known Test Failures** - PR description admits tests will fail - Ticket #53 AC requires: "All controller tests pass" - Tests must be updated to pass ### Recommendation: Before re-submission, the team should decide: - Option A: Implement Alba with JSON:API compatible output - Option B: Accept breaking change and update epic acceptance criteria - Option C: Add API versioning (v1 = old format, v2 = new format) See reviewer_audit artifact for detailed findings.