## Code Review - Round 2 ### Previous Issues Addressed All issues from previous review have been fixed: | Issue | Status | Fix | |-------|--------|-----| | Missing `withdrawn` in status validation test | ✅ Fixed | Line 19 now includes "withdrawn" | | Missing `withdrawn?` predicate test | ✅ Fixed | Lines 128-138 test `withdrawn?` | | Missing `scope :withdrawn` | ✅ Fixed | Added to model at line 18 | | Missing `.withdrawn` scope test | ✅ Fixed | Lines 68-76 test the scope | ### Test Results - Test suite: `bundle exec rspec` - Results: 700 examples, 2 failures, 7 pending **Note:** The 2 failing tests are pre-existing dashboard_spec.rb issues unrelated to this PR. ### Spec Coverage Check - All model changes covered by `spec/models/proposal_spec.rb` (35 examples, 0 failures) - All MCP tool changes covered by `spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb` (18 execute_proposal tests) ### Decision **PASS** - All previous issues resolved. The PR now has complete spec coverage for: - `withdrawn` status in validation - `withdrawn?` predicate - `scope :withdrawn` - Full execute_proposal MCP functionality