## Epic Review - #132: Researcher Agent ### Summary This Epic introduced a **Researcher agent** that runs 24/7 to analyze the codebase and create proposals for human review. The implementation includes the proposal system, MCP tools, and admin UI. ### Subtasks Status | ID | Title | Status | |----|-------|--------| | 133 | Create proposal system | ✅ Done (PR #67) | | 134 | Set up Researcher agent | ✅ Done (PR #82) | | 135 | Phase 1 (MVP): Memory/ticket pattern analysis | ✅ Done (PR #83) | | 136 | Phase 2: Code quality analysis | ❌ Cancelled | | 137 | Phase 3: Feature ideation | ❌ Cancelled | | 138 | Phase 4: 24/7 operation, UI, batch approval | ✅ Done (PR #84) | ### Implementation Verified **1. Proposal System (Task #133) ✅** - `Proposal` model exists with all fields: title, proposal_type, reasoning, confidence, priority, status, metadata, ticket_id, agent_id - `ProposalsController` with index, show, create actions - API endpoints: GET/POST `/api/v1/proposals` - 33 proposal tests passing **2. Researcher Agent (Task #134) ✅** - `researcher` role added to Agent model enum - Researcher agent exists in database (1 confirmed) - Guardrails enforced: read-only access + create_proposal only - MCP tools available: create_proposal, list_proposals, delete_proposal, search_memory, store_memory **3. Phase 1 (Task #135) ✅** - `researcher_reviewed_at` columns added to tickets, memories, comments - Migration: `20251230082330_add_researcher_reviewed_at_to_tickets_and_memories.rb` - MCP tools support `reviewed_before` filtering for catching up on backlog **4. Phase 4 (Task #138) ✅** - Proposals UI at `/proposals` - Views: index.html.haml, _proposal_card.html.haml, _metrics.html.haml - Avo admin resource with filters and batch actions - Avo actions: ApproveProposal, RejectProposal, ApproveProposalsBatch ### Test Results - Full suite: **687 examples, 5 failures, 7 pending** - The 5 failures are pre-existing issues unrelated to this epic: - dashboard_spec.rb (2 failures - UI/Capybara issues) - rejection workflow tests (3 failures - ticket status expectations) ### Cancelled Phases **Phase 2 (Code Quality Analysis)** - Cancelled - Would have added: code smell detection, duplication analysis, test coverage gaps - Not critical for MVP **Phase 3 (Feature Ideation)** - Cancelled - Would have added: workflow analysis, UX improvement suggestions - Not critical for MVP ### Decision **PASS** - Epic is complete for the implemented phases The core Researcher agent functionality is working: - Proposal system ✅ - MCP tools ✅ - Admin UI ✅ - Review tracking ✅ The cancelled phases (code quality analysis, feature ideation) are nice-to-haves that can be added later if needed. The 24/7 operation capability exists and can be triggered via WebSocket or scheduled job.