## AUDIT DECISION: FAIL **Ticket:** #140 - Forbid bare HTTP status checks in tests **PR:** #85 **Reviewer:** tinker-reviewer ### Reason for Failure This PR cannot pass audit due to **critical issues** that must be addressed: 1. **Unrelated migration file** - `db/migrate/20251231014126_add_last_activity_at_to_agent_sessions.rb` has nothing to do with this ticket. This adds `last_activity_at` column to agent_sessions - a completely different feature that should be in its own PR. 2. **Stale reference to non-existent file** - `spec/support/response_matchers.rb:8-9` references `config/initializers/patch_rspec_for_better_test_errors.rb` which doesn't exist. 3. **Monkeypatch effectiveness unverified** - No test demonstrates that the warning is actually shown when a bare `have_http_status` is used. The implementation approach may not work with RSpec's matcher system. ### Required Fixes 1. Remove the unrelated migration file and schema changes from this PR 2. Update the stale comment in response_matchers.rb to point to `spec/support/bare_status_check_enforcer.rb` 3. Add a test demonstrating that bare status checks trigger the warning ### What Was Good - ✅ Warning message is well-formatted and helpful - ✅ Memory stored (ID #61) with anti-pattern instruction - ✅ Test suite passes (2 pre-existing failures unrelated to this PR) See code review comment #154 for detailed findings.