## Code Review: PR #82 (Updated - Re-review) ### Spec Pattern Search (REQUIRED) - Searched for existing spec patterns: `find spec -name "*mcp*" -o -name "*proposal*"` - Found existing spec files: - spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb (MCP tool integration tests) - spec/models/proposal_spec.rb (Proposal model specs) - spec/models/mcp_synchronization_spec.rb (MCP role config validation) - spec/factories/agents.rb (now includes :researcher trait) ### Test Results - Test suite run: `bundle exec rspec` - Results: **629 examples, 0 failures, 10 pending** (pending unrelated to this PR) - MCP tests specifically: **57 examples, 0 failures** - Agent + MCP sync tests: **61 examples, 0 failures** ### Spec Coverage Check - Files changed in PR (7 files): 1. agents.rb (system prompt) - No tests needed (configuration) 2. app/models/agent.rb (researcher type, has_many :proposals) - Covered by agent_spec ✓ 3. app/controllers/api/v1/mcp_controller.rb (create_proposal, list_proposals tools + handlers) - **NOW TESTED** ✓ 4. config/tinker/mcp_permissions.yml (researcher permissions) - Covered by mcp_synchronization_spec ✓ 5. spec/factories/agents.rb (researcher trait) - Test support ✓ 6. spec/models/mcp_synchronization_spec.rb (updated known_roles) - ✓ 7. spec/requests/api/v1/mcp_spec.rb (**NEW TESTS ADDED**) - ✓ ### New Test Coverage (11 examples added) **create_proposal tests (4 examples):** - ✓ Creates a proposal via MCP (researcher only) - ✓ Returns access denied for workers attempting to create proposals - ✓ Validates required parameters - ✓ Applies default values for confidence and priority **list_proposals tests (7 examples):** - ✓ Lists proposals scoped to agent's project - ✓ Filters by status - ✓ Filters by proposal_type - ✓ Filters by confidence - ✓ Filters by priority - ✓ Respects limit parameter - ✓ Includes proposal details in response ### Findings - **Code quality:** Clean implementation, proper project-scoped queries, well-structured system prompt - **Security:** Permissions correctly configured (researcher is read-only + create_proposal) - **Implementation:** Matches ticket #134 requirements - **Test coverage:** Comprehensive - all new MCP tools have full integration tests ### Decision **PASS - All tests pass, comprehensive test coverage added** The previous review feedback has been fully addressed. The PR now includes: 1. 11 new integration tests for create_proposal and list_proposals MCP tools 2. Researcher factory trait for test support 3. All 629 tests passing with 0 failures