## Code Review: PASS - Merge Conflicts Resolved ### ✅ Previous Issue Fixed The worker resolved the merge conflicts in `db/schema.rb`. The schema now cleanly includes both: - `proposals` table with proper indexes - `solid_queue_*` tables (from main branch) - Foreign keys for both No conflict markers remain. ### ✅ All Acceptance Criteria Met 1. **Proposals table exists with all fields** ✓ - title, proposal_type, reasoning, confidence, priority, status - JSON metadata for evidence_links - Optional ticket_id, agent_id foreign keys - Proper indexes on queryable fields 2. **Metadata stored as JSON with evidence_links** ✓ - `metadata["evidence_links"]` accessor method - `add_evidence_link` method for adding links - Supports type (ticket/memory/code_file), id, path, description 3. **API endpoints work** ✓ - POST /api/v1/proposals - Create - GET /api/v1/proposals - List with filters - GET /api/v1/proposals/:id - Show - POST /api/v1/proposals/:id/approve - Approve - POST /api/v1/proposals/:id/reject - Reject - POST /api/v1/proposals/approve_batch - Bulk approve 4. **Avo admin interface** ✓ - Resource with filters (status, type, priority) - Show page with metadata display - Approve/Reject actions - Batch approve action 5. **Searchable and filterable** ✓ - Scopes: pending, approved, rejected, executed - Scopes: by_priority, by_confidence, by_type, by_agent - Status predicate methods (pending?, approved?, etc.) ### Code Quality **Model (`app/models/proposal.rb`):** - Comprehensive validations with inclusion constraints - Clear status workflow (pending → approved/rejected → executed) - Rejection feedback stored in AgentMemory for learning - Evidence link helpers **Controller (`app/controllers/api/v1/proposals_controller.rb`):** - Proper filtering, sorting, pagination - Error handling with meaningful messages - Batch approve functionality **Avo Resources:** - Clean admin interface with filters - Actions for approve/reject/batch ### Test Results - **Proposal model tests: 27 examples, 0 failures** ✓ ### Note on Other Test Failures Some tests in the broader suite fail due to a pre-existing issue: the tickets factory still references `acceptance_criteria` column that was removed in PR #74. This is **not caused by this PR** and affects the entire codebase. ### Recommendation: PASS The merge conflicts have been resolved, the proposal system is well-implemented with comprehensive tests, and all acceptance criteria are met. The pre-existing factory issue is a separate concern.