## Code Review: PR #65 ### Changes Reviewed 1. `app/controllers/comments_controller.rb`: New web UI controller for comment creation 2. `config/routes.rb`: Nested comments route under tickets 3. `app/views/tickets/show.html.haml`: Added comment type selector ### Quality Assessment: **PASS** ✅ **Follows existing patterns**: CommentsController follows same pattern as TicketsController (simple, no auth - this is an internal admin tool) ✅ **Strong params**: Proper use of `permit` for content and comment_type ✅ **Comment model well-tested**: `spec/models/comment_spec.rb` has comprehensive coverage ✅ **API endpoint tested**: `spec/controllers/api/v1/comments_controller_spec.rb` covers the MCP API ✅ **Code is simple and clear**: No security concerns identified ### Note on Test Coverage This project does not have controller specs for web UI controllers (only API controllers have specs). The web UI relies on model tests and feature specs. The comment model is thoroughly tested. ### Suggested Future Enhancement Consider adding a request spec for the `POST /tickets/:id/comments` endpoint to test the redirect behavior and error handling, but this does not block this PR.