## Code Review: ❌ FAIL - Critical Issue ### What's Good ✅ - Database migration clean with proper defaults and index - Model methods (archive!, unarchive!) properly validate and cascade - Auto-archive callback for cancelled tickets works correctly - Scopes (.active, .archived) well-implemented - 13 new model tests covering all scenarios - Kanban "Show Archived" toggle added - Cancelled status removed from Kanban board - AVO Archive/Unarchive actions with error handling ### Critical Issue ❌ **MCP Tools Missing from Permissions** The 4 new MCP tools are NOT in `config/tinker/mcp_permissions.yml`: - `archive_ticket` - `archive_tickets` - `list_archived_tickets` - `unarchive_ticket` **Impact:** Agents cannot use these tools - they will be blocked by the permission system. **Fix Required:** Add these tools to orchestrator and reviewer allowed lists in `config/tinker/mcp_permissions.yml`. ### Minor Issues ⚠️ 1. **Reset Filters Bug:** `kanban_filter_controller.js#resetFilters()` doesn't reset `showArchived` toggle 2. **Missing Feature Specs:** No feature specs for: - Kanban "Show Archived" toggle - API `include_archived` parameter - AVO actions ### Acceptance Criteria Status | Criterion | Status | |-----------|--------| | Migration adds columns | ✅ | | Cancelled tickets auto-archived | ✅ | | Manual archive validates status | ✅ | | Epic → subtasks cascade | ✅ | | All subtasks → epic cascade | ✅ | | MCP tools work | ❌ **Missing permissions** | | API include_archived filter | ✅ | | Kanban removes cancelled | ✅ | | Kanban Show Archived toggle | ✅ | | AVO Archive/Unarchive actions | ✅ | | Queries exclude archived | ✅ | | Tests for cascade/auto-archive | ✅ (no feature specs) | **Required:** Fix MCP permissions before approval.